Games like Tibia
Ranked by how closely each game's gameplay profile, monetization, and world design match Tibia — not by popularity. Similarity blends attribute distance across PvE/PvP focus, grind, combat, and social systems with shared tags and curated links.
Tibia is a sandbox MMO with tab-target combat on a free-to-play + sub option model. Of the picks below, 9 of 10 share its open-world PvP, 8 of 10 share its sandbox world and 8 of 10 share its tab-target combat.

Ultima Online
#1 · 93% similar
vs Tibia: Ultima Online is easier to catch up in, deeper on crafting and more alt-friendly.

Apogea
#2 · 93% similar
vs Tibia: Apogea is seen as less pay-to-win and less grindy, with a free-to-play model instead of free-to-play + sub option.

Old School RuneScape
#3 · 86% similar
vs Tibia: Old School RuneScape is deeper on crafting, less guild-dependent and seen as less pay-to-win.

Ravendawn
#4 · 81% similar
vs Tibia: Ravendawn is deeper on crafting, less PvE-focused and less grindy.

Torebia: Island Odyssey
#5 · 77% similar
vs Tibia: Torebia: Island Odyssey is seen as less pay-to-win, with a free-to-play model instead of free-to-play + sub option and no open-world PvP.
UO Outlands
#6 · 75% similar
vs Tibia: UO Outlands is deeper on crafting and more alt-friendly, with a free-to-play model instead of free-to-play + sub option.

Broken Ranks
#7 · 73% similar
vs Tibia: Broken Ranks with a themepark world instead of a sandbox world, turn-based combat instead of tab-target combat and a free-to-play model instead of free-to-play + sub option.

Haven & Hearth
#8 · 71% similar
vs Tibia: Haven & Hearth is heavier on scheduled chores, deeper on crafting and more PvP-focused.

Wurm Online
#9 · 68% similar
vs Tibia: Wurm Online is deeper on crafting, less PvE-focused and less PvP-focused.

Helbreath
#10 · 68% similar
vs Tibia: Helbreath with a sandpark world instead of a sandbox world, soft-lock action combat instead of tab-target combat and a free-to-play model instead of free-to-play + sub option.
Not quite it? The Find My MMO quiz matches on how you play instead of on one game.